
I first heard about this book when I held Body Image and Self-Perfection Month two years ago, when another blogger taking part reviewed it. I was intrigued as to how a graphic novel would deal with such a serious subject, and now I've read it, I'm in two minds.
I think Tyranny is a great way to get your first glimpse of what living with anorexia is like, as it covers years of Anna's life and how it effected her. It's a great way to get the discussion going or at least think about it as an individual, but being a graphic novel, there isn't much opportunity really get into the emotional side of things that comes along with the narrative of a novel. However, Tyranny gets as close as I think a graphic novel can, covering the self-loathing and how those with anorexia see themselves completely differently to what's real. It doesn't shy away from the seriousness of the illness, or how badly things can go. I covers the whole journey right from the very first diet to recovery and becoming well again, and everything inbetween.
However, I do think it isn't as shocking or as scary as it can be on the subject. Maybe it's me; I'm not the biggest fan of graphic novels, or maybe it's the length, I read it in about 10-15 minutes, but I found myself detached from the story. It wasn't as hard hitting as I think a story about such things should be.
I also wasn't the biggest fan of the style, the language was very simple and almost childlike, and I found the character of Tyranny to be annoying and pretty silly, rather than freaky. I still say it's a pretty good introduction into the fiction side of things to do with this subject, and well worth a read.
Thank you to Walker for the review copy.
Published: 7th February 2011
Publisher: Walker
Lesle Fairfield's Website
This sounded really interesting until I read "graphic novel." Honestly - I think graphic novels are great for some, they just don't work for me. But the idea behind this is great. I'm glad that they were willing to delve into such a serious subject. Good review.
ReplyDeleteThank you! :) Yeah, I'm not the biggest graphic novel fan, but I don't want to write them all off just yet. It was good to see the subject tackled in this form, but I do think novels do a better job generally.
DeleteI definitely agree with what you said about their being some distance emotionally with this book. I think that was the intention actually. But it doesn't quite work for some people - like you and me!
ReplyDeleteIntentional? That seems so odd. Sure, the effects of anorexia are shocking, but it shocks even more when you're emotionally involved. At least for me. I need to be involved.
Delete