Monday, 15 November 2010

Review: Matched by Ally Condie

Matched by Ally CondieMatched by Ally Condie (review copy) - On her seventeenth birthday, Cassia meets her Match. Society dictates he is her perfect partner for life. Except he’s not. In Cassia’s society, Officials decide who people love. How many children they have. Where they work. When they die. But, as Cassia finds herself falling in love with another boy, she is determined to make some choices of her own. And that’s when her whole world begins to unravel... From Amazon UK

When I first heard about this book, I was so intrigued! A book where the government chooses who you spend the rest of your life with?! This has got to be worth reading! Now I'm finished, I have to say, I was pretty disappointed.

The plot is pretty fascinating; a world set way in the future, where everyone is governed by probability and statistics. They live a way an "optimal" life as worked out by Society. They are Matched with the optimal partner, to produce optimal, healthy offspring. They eat what Society has found to give them the optimal nutrients to keep them healthy - regardless of taste. They are given the job they will do best at - the possibility of them may not liking it doesn't come into it. They die when Society states they've lived an optimal life, and it's probable that they will deteriorate and have a less than optimal life from that time onwards. The perfect life, right? Where everyone has what's best for them, live the best life they can? No!

There is no free will. It seems like there is, but there isn't. How they spend their free recreation hours on a Saturday evening is up to them - as long as it's either games, a showing, or going to the music hall. They get to have a free summer activity which they can choose - but involves them doing work. Society declared their culture was too cluttered, so everything was sorted, so there are now the Hundred Songs, the Hundred Paintings, the Hundred Poems, etc. Everything is controlled. Everything is worked out. Society considers all possible factors, and predicts the probability of even everyone's reactions to different events, their behaviour, and the type of person they will be. It's Big Brother gone mad.

This book is all about fighting, striving for change, for the right to choice and free will. What I liked most was the power that words held for Cassia. During his Death Banquet, Cassias grandfather gives her paper with two poems on them. Grandfather's own Grandmother was one of the people who were called to sort out the poetry and narrow it down to just the Hundred Poems. She stole some, and handed them down. These poems hold such importance for Cassia; not just because they are forbidden, but because of what they tell you - to fight. Society has also forbidden writing, so no-one ever learns how to write. They have their Scribes, where they can type, but they can't write with their hands. Ky, one of the guys who lives in her borough, can. And he teaches her. First, Cassia learns to write her name, and it's such a powerful moment, of almost ownership - she can write her own name. All these acts of rebellion - forbidden writing, forbidden poems, rebellion actually in the poem, and eventually, forbidden love - spark something inside Cassia. It's great to see her change from someone who believes in the Society, and that it keeps them safe, that they all live good lives, to someone who questions everything she knows.

However, apart from Ky, I didn't find the characters believable. They were two dimensional as opposed to three dimensional. I didn't feel anything for them, because there wasn't enough to make me feel. I was indifferent to everyone except Ky. I think this was also because of the pace. It's not fast or slow, it's average. And there's no real suspense. It all seems to be chugging along on on flat level. No rollercoaster in this book. At the beginning, I was intrigued, but then, until things started to develop with Ky, and we learned more about him, and the importance of words, I just wasn't interested, and, to be frank, bored. I read on because I can't start a book and not finish it. I just can't do it. But if I did, I would have stopped reading. I also think I've discovered that dystopian novels aren't really my thing. There may be a few dystopian novels that I like, but as a genre, I don't think it's my cup of tea.

I must say, it is the kind of book I think will make an amazing movie, so I'm really glad there will be a chance to see it on the big screen!

However, there is a lot about this novel that fans of dystopian will love. The way people are governed, the technology, the sheer wrongness of it all that makes a dystopian. I'm sure there are a lot of people who will - and who have - loved this book. I suggest you check out some other reviews of Matched (see below) before you decide just by my review. Matched could have turned out to be such an amazing boook, it had a lot of promise, it just unfortunately fell flat for me.

Thank you to Puffin for sending me a review copy.

Published: 2nd December 2010
Publisher: Puffin
Pre-order on Amazon UK
Pre-order on Amazon US
Ally Condie's Website

Other reviews of Matched:
I Was a Teenage Book Geek
Fluttering Butterflies
Pure Imagination

10 comments:

  1. I'm really looking forward to seeing what side I fall on about this book. Great review, Jo!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Woa!! This sounds horrible. No freedom in life and everything's decided by goverment. This can drives me crazy!! Haha....absolutely a unique and original book. Great review, Jo!!

    My latest review: HERE

    ReplyDelete
  3. (Sorry about the deletion.) Wonderful review! I loved reading it. Thanks, Jo!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Sophie - Thank you! I really hope you like it. It's a shame I didn't. It had such potential!

    Cj'alhafiz - Thank you. It is a pretty intriguing plot, I must say. I hope you enjoy it if you read it :)

    Luisa - Thank you, and no problem! :)

    ReplyDelete
  5. I've heard mixed reviews on this one and it sounds interesting, so I'm glad to read another positive review :)

    ReplyDelete
  6. This isn't really a positive review. There were good parts about it, but I was disappointed over all. But I hope you enjoy it if you read it.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Great review! I'm really curious about this one since there's been so much talk about it. It's a shame you didn't feel much for the characters, just because they live in a world where there isn't much to feel doesn't mean they have to be bidimensional!

    ReplyDelete
  8. Thank you! I have to say they definitely feel, just in their ignorant way. They're still passionate - but just over what they're allowed to be passionate about. It's just... flat, in my opinion. I hope you enjoy it if you read it! :)

    ReplyDelete
  9. You've literally just described my feelings towards this book. I read the blurb, loved it. Read it, finished it and was disappointed. You are 100% right about how it went along at an average speed, no rollarcoastar, etc. I don't think I'll be reading 'crossed'.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yeah, I didn't really enjoy it much. It's a shame really. But don't let it put you off dystopia in general! I kind of did that, and regret it now! So many dystopian novels I took a long time to get to that are just awesome! :)

      Delete